I’ve been comparing this behavior with other editors (KWave, interestingly Tenacity/Audacity doesn’t have a drag function), and you were right (once again XD). The logic is correct; what’s incorrect is the graphical representation of the functionality.
The dashed selection rectangle shouldn’t shift until the mouse pointer moves beyond the edges of the blue selection area.
The mouse pointer should appear in the center of the selection—not at the corner—and then move toward the edges.
The dashed area shouldn’t shift until the mouse pointer moves past one of its edges.
That said, my logic was also correct—it was just a different approach.
PS
Getting this functionality to work well from a visual standpoint is complicated—and, clearly, it doesn’t work well right now.
When you factor in "snapping," even if we managed to get it working, the experience would be cumbersome and confusing for the user, as they would need to be able to move elements beyond the...
However, a approach cut/paste drag assisted would work well; it would be simple to implement and would also help simplify the codebase.
I know I’m being annoying. Please understand that I say this out of respect, even if it might not always come across that way.
I’ve been comparing this behavior with other editors (KWave, interestingly Tenacity/Audacity doesn’t have a drag function), and you were right (once again XD). The logic is correct; what’s incorrect is the graphical representation of the functionality.
The dashed selection rectangle shouldn’t shift until the mouse pointer moves beyond the edges of the blue selection area.
The mouse pointer should appear in the center of the selection—not at the corner—and then move toward the edges.
The dashed area shouldn’t shift until the mouse pointer moves past one of its edges.
That said, my logic was also correct—it was just a different approach.
PS
Getting this functionality to work well from a visual standpoint is complicated—and, clearly, it doesn’t work well right now.
When you factor in "snapping," even if we managed to get it working, the experience would be cumbersome and confusing for the user, as they would need to be able to move elements beyond the...
However, a approach cut/paste drag assisted would work well; it would be simple to implement and would also help simplify the codebase.
I know I’m being annoying. Please understand that I say this out of respect, even if it might not always come across that way.