Forums
I'll leave you this here: current git head has some lurking features, waiting for your kind judgement
but still, the plan goes like this:
- next coming v1.6.5, won't get those whatsoever;
- v1.7.0 will be The One ;)
meanwhile and for what is this all about, you ask?
hint: start build with cmake -DCONFIG_AUDIO_EDITOR=ON.. and maybe you'll get initiated to the cause ;)
wholly cheers!
Questions
1_
Every time an audio file is modified, a new file is created. Is this the intended final behavior?
This will quickly fill up our hard drives in just a single session.
The MIDI editor only creates a new file when strictly necessary, otherwise overwriting changes within the existing file—even though space is not a major concern with MIDI.
I believe audio editing should work the same way.
A new file should only be generated upon the first edit after opening the editor; subsequent edits should simply overwrite the existing file.
The same logic should apply if you close and reopen the editor. While new files might still be created for safety, the total number of files would be reduced exponentially.
2_
When copying and pasting an audio clip (now that an editor is available), the expected behavior, consistent with MIDI, is the creation of linked clips or instances. This would allow for looping, where editing a single sample automatically updates all its instances.
re. Questions...
yes.
that would be nice, but not feasible I'm afraid.
audio clip files are not kept the in same way as MIDI clips, for which all events are kept in memory, all the time; audio files are not, and never will, should I add, so sorry.
unfortunately that is not possible
most of all, you need to cope with undo and redo's, so that the only current practical way to go with this is having a complete unique file for each edit change.
that's is the way of how the new audio clip editor works, yes, pretty naive and brute force indeed, but that's what we have here and ain't gonna change so soon.
well, that might be a thing in the near future, we'll see about that when the dust settles down.
but more importantly, all of this questions boils down to a simple truth of life: don't ever use the new audio clip editor to edit large, or heaven forbids, BIG files although it will be perfectly possible to do so, you will end spoiling trashing disk space, not to tell of your human time while doing so.
hyu.
cheers.
re1. Questions
You’ve convinced me.
Considering that we have the split and merge tools available, allowing us to edit only the specific segment needed, the current approach is actually quite efficient.
Thanks for clearing up the doubts :)
Order audio edit / audio properties
At the moment a double click (or a shortcut) opens the audio editor. I can then open the old properties dialog.
There's no shortcut for the old properties dialog.
In most cases I want to edit something in the properties dialog. So I'd like to have the reverse thing: double click opens the properties and there I have an icon to open the audio editor.
My proposal:
Add an icon in the audio clip properties to open the audio editor and add a switch in view->options->audio to reverse the logic, i.e. what opens first at double click.
re1. Order audio edit / audio properties
And furthermore, why not?, let’s add access to properties to the menu and the clip’s context menu.
Easy access to properties is, for me, something fundamental.
re2. Order audio edit / audio properties...
as suggested earlier by @G3N-es, there will be separate Clip > Edit... and Clip > Properties...
just let v1.6.5 get officially out, in a few hours, please
case dismissed, for now :)
cheers.
re3. Order audio edit / audio properties...
That's fine but wouldn't leave a choice what happens when double clicking an audio clip.
Of course opening an editor as with midi clips is the consistent way when seen from a general perspective.
Making the old double click behaviour available by providing a switch would be perfect.
re4. Order audio edit / audio properties...
what about this not having yet another exquisite option:
?
re5. Order audio edit / audio properties
Would also be fine.
re8. Order audio edit / audio properties...
Still to do:
Update the "properties" icon in the editors.
(I assume you're already aware of this, but a quick reminder never hurts! XD)
I find this a very satisfactory solution.
I like that the "edit" button doesn't appear in the main toolbar, since the obvious way to access it is by clicking on the clip. Including it there as well wouldn't add any value.
Thanks a lot, Rui. This is taking on an incredible color.
re6. Order audio edit / audio properties...
done.
qtractor >= v1.6.5.1git.dafb75 [develop]
nb. now that v1.6.5 is officially out the road to v1.7.0 has begun to be paved ;)
cheers
ps. no need to
cmake -DCONFIG_AUDIO_EDITOR=ON... no more.re7. Order audio edit / audio properties...
Works fine.
Add new comment